Think back to your favorite Christmas cookie. That soft, buttery sugar cookie that melts in your mouth, topped with frosting and festive sprinkles. Now imagine sipping that same flavor—but with a kick. That’s exactly what the Sugar Cookie Martini delivers.

This cocktail isn’t just a drink; it’s a dessert in a glass. It’s smooth, sweet, creamy, and dangerously easy to drink. Perfect for holiday parties, girls’ nights, or just treating yourself after a long day of shopping or wrapping presents.

The Sugar Cookie Martini takes the nostalgic flavor of your childhood favorite and gives it a grown-up twist—with just enough booze to keep things merry and bright. If you’re looking for a holiday cocktail that’s easy to make, looks like a showstopper, and tastes like Christmas, you’ve just found it.

A Sugar Cookie Martini is a sweet, dessert-style cocktail that captures the essence of a frosted sugar cookie in liquid form. It’s rich and creamy, with notes of vanilla, almond, and just a hint of warm holiday magic.

This martini is made using vanilla vodka, Irish cream liqueur, amaretto (an almond-flavored liqueur), and milk. The result? A perfectly blended treat that’s smooth and decadent without being overly heavy.

It’s one of those drinks that’s perfect for sipping while watching Christmas movies or passing around presents. Think of it as the adult version of that glass of milk you used to leave out for Santa—only this time, you get to enjoy it.

Table of Contents

The Star Ingredients and What They Bring

This cocktail might only have a handful of ingredients, but each one plays a vital role in bringing that sugar cookie flavor to life.

Here’s a quick breakdown:

Vanilla Vodka: Adds sweetness and depth with that vanilla cookie note

Irish Cream: Brings creamy, chocolaty, coffee-like richness
Amaretto: The secret to that sweet almond cookie flavor
Milk: Softens everything and gives it that sugar cookie texture
Frosting + Sprinkles: The finishing touch that makes it festive and fun

It’s all about balance. You want the drink to taste like a cookie—sweet, buttery, and rich—without being overwhelming. That’s where the milk comes in to smooth things out.

Vanilla vodka is the foundation of this cocktail. It sets the tone for that iconic sugar cookie flavor by adding both a sweet vanilla essence and a boozy backbone. Without it, the drink lacks that punchy, sweet-cookie aroma.

When choosing a vanilla vodka, go for one that isn’t too artificial or overly sweet. A few great options:

Absolut Vanilla
Stoli Vanil
Smirnoff Vanilla (great budget option)
Tito’s (infuse with vanilla bean yourself for a DIY version)

If you don’t have vanilla vodka on hand, you can substitute plain vodka with a splash of vanilla extract—but be warned, the flavor won’t be as smooth.

Either way, the vanilla vodka gives your martini that familiar sugar cookie warmth right from the first sip.

Irish Cream: The Creamy Sweetheart

Irish cream is the secret ingredient that turns this drink from cocktail to dessert. It’s sweet, smooth, and has a touch of cocoa and coffee flavor that rounds out the richness beautifully.

Popular Irish cream options include:

Baileys (the classic)
Carolans (a great budget option)
Emmets
Homemade Irish cream if you’re feeling crafty

This ingredient makes the drink velvety and thick, almost like a milkshake—but boozier. If you’re a fan of creamy cocktails like White Russians or Mudslides, you’re going to love what Irish cream brings to the table here.

Amaretto: The Almond Kick

Amaretto might just be the most underrated holiday cocktail ingredient. With its sweet, nutty flavor, it gives this martini its signature sugar-cookie-almond flavor. Just one ounce of amaretto adds complexity and warmth, rounding out the sweetness from the vodka and Irish cream.

Try brands like:

Disaronno (the gold standard)
Lazzaroni Amaretto
Luxardo Amaretto

If you don’t have amaretto, you could try a few drops of almond extract instead—but be careful, it’s strong and not nearly as smooth.

The amaretto really takes this from “vanilla cocktail” to “full-on sugar cookie in a glass.”

Milk: The Balancer

Milk might seem like a simple ingredient, but don’t underestimate its role. It balances out the strong liqueurs and gives the drink that classic sugar cookie texture—light, creamy, and just rich enough.

Here are some milk options and how they affect the cocktail:

Whole milk: Creamy and full-bodied—perfect balance
2% milk: Slightly lighter, still works great
Half and half: Ultra-rich for a more indulgent sip
Oat milk or almond milk: Great dairy-free options, just be sure they’re unsweetened

Now that you know what each ingredient brings to the party, let’s get to the fun part—making the actual drink. The Sugar Cookie Martini is one of those cocktails that looks fancy but is super simple to throw together.

Ingredients:

2 oz vanilla vodka
1 oz Irish cream
1 oz amaretto
1 oz milk (or milk alternative)
Frosting (for rimming the glass)
Holiday sprinkles (for garnish)
Ice

Instructions:

Rim the Glass:
- Start by prepping your martini glass.
- Take a spoonful of vanilla or buttercream frosting and run it around the rim.
- Dip the frosted rim into a plate of colorful holiday sprinkles.
- Set the glass aside.
Mix the Drink:
- In a cocktail shaker filled with ice, pour in the vanilla vodka, Irish cream, amaretto, and milk.
- Shake vigorously for 15–20 seconds. You want everything super cold and well-blended.
Strain and Serve:
- Strain the mixture into your rimmed martini glass.
- Optional: Top with a small dollop of whipped cream or a mini sugar cookie for extra fun.

And voilà! You’ve got yourself a Sugar Cookie Martini that’s not only delicious but absolutely Instagram-worthy.

How to Rim the Glass with Frosting and Sprinkles Like a Pro

This part isn’t just for looks—it adds texture, sweetness, and festive vibes to your drink. Here’s how to make it perfect every time:

Step-by-Step Frosted Rim:

Take a butter knife or small spatula and apply a thin, even layer of frosting around the rim of the glass. Go for about ¼ inch thickness.
Pour your sprinkles onto a shallow plate or saucer.
Gently roll the rim of the frosted glass through the sprinkles until it’s completely coated.
Let it sit for a minute so the frosting firms up a bit before pouring the drink.

Pro Tips:

Use white frosting for a snow-like look, or get playful with colored frosting.
Try crushed cookies, sanding sugar, or edible glitter for a different twist.
Chill the glass before rimming—it helps the frosting stick better.

The rim not only adds extra sweetness, but it also turns every sip into a little celebration.

Want to wow your guests at your next holiday get-together? Make a batch version of the Sugar Cookie Martini so you can mingle instead of mixing drinks all night.

Batch Recipe (Serves 8):

2 cups vanilla vodka
1 cup Irish cream
1 cup amaretto
1 cup milk
Optional: ½ cup half-and-half for extra creaminess

Instructions:

Mix all ingredients in a large pitcher.
Store in the fridge until ready to serve.
Rim individual glasses with frosting and sprinkles just before serving.

Stir the pitcher well before each pour—ingredients may settle.

This batch version keeps beautifully in the fridge for up to 3 days. Just don’t add ice directly into the pitcher (it’ll dilute the flavor).

Want to play with flavors or cater to different tastes? Here are a few tasty twists:

Add ½ oz peppermint schnapps
Rim with crushed candy canes

Add ½ oz chocolate liqueur (like Godiva)
Garnish with cocoa powder or chocolate shavings

Use plant-based milk (oat or almond)
Swap Irish cream for a vegan cream liqueur (Baileys Almande works well)

Drizzle caramel syrup inside the glass
Add ½ oz caramel vodka or butterscotch schnapps

Add a pinch of cinnamon and nutmeg to the shaker
Rim with crushed gingersnaps or cinnamon sugar

With these variations, you can keep the sugar cookie vibe alive all season long, without ever getting bored.

Perfect Garnishes to Dress It Up

Garnishing isn’t just about looks—it enhances the overall flavor and experience. Here are some fun and festive ideas:

Mini sugar cookies on a cocktail stick
Whipped cream and colored sugar crystals
Maraschino cherry for a pop of color
Cinnamon stick for a warm, wintry vibe
Edible glitter for sparkle and shine

Presentation is half the fun of this drink, so get creative and have fun with it. After all, it’s Christmas!

When and Where to Serve This Cocktail

The Sugar Cookie Martini is a versatile showstopper. Whether you’re sipping solo while wrapping gifts or hosting a full-blown holiday bash, this cocktail fits in beautifully. Here’s when it truly shines:

Best Occasions to Serve It:

Christmas Eve by the fireplace
Holiday girls’ night or cookie exchange parties
Festive brunch (yes, martinis before noon!)
New Year’s Eve dessert drink
Office holiday party (off the clock, of course!)

It’s also great for a signature holiday cocktail. If you’re planning a Christmas dinner or event, serve this as your “official drink.” You can even print out cute little recipe cards for guests to take home.

And don’t forget the holiday movie night. Sip this while watching Elf, Home Alone, or The Grinch, and it just might become your new favorite holiday tradition.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

The Sugar Cookie Martini may be simple to make, but even the easiest cocktails can go sideways if you’re not careful. Here are some mistakes to steer clear of:

1. Using Low-Quality Vodka

Cheap vodka = harsh flavor. This drink is all about smooth, creamy sweetness, so choose a decent vanilla vodka to avoid a bitter edge.

2. Skipping the Shake

Don’t just stir it—shake it! Shaking with ice chills the drink quickly and helps blend the thick liqueurs for a smoother sip.

3. Using Warm Ingredients

Always use chilled ingredients. No one wants a lukewarm martini. Bonus points if you chill your glass beforehand.

4. Rushing the Rim

Take your time with the frosting and sprinkles. If you rush it, the sprinkles may fall off—or worse, the frosting will slide.

5. Going Overboard on Garnish

Yes, garnish is fun, but too much can make it messy. Stick with one or two cute touches (like whipped cream + sprinkles) and keep it balanced.

Avoid these slip-ups and you’ll be sipping like a holiday cocktail pro in no time.

This drink is basically dessert already, but if you really want to lean into the indulgence (and you should—it’s the holidays!), here are some dreamy desserts to serve with it:

Perfect Pairings:

Frosted sugar cookies (go figure)
Almond biscotti for dipping
White chocolate fudge
Cinnamon rolls or sticky buns
Cheesecake with a vanilla or almond crust
Snickerdoodles or shortbread cookies

If you’re going for dessert overload (which we fully support), add a cookie charcuterie board with various treats. Your Sugar Cookie Martini will complement them all and make you the holiday host of the year.

The Sugar Cookie Martini is more than a cocktail—it’s a holiday moment. It’s rich without being too heavy, festive without being complicated, and nostalgic in all the best ways. One sip and you’re transported to a kitchen full of freshly baked cookies, twinkling lights, and cozy laughter.

It’s the kind of drink that feels like a reward at the end of a long winter’s day. The frosting-and-sprinkles rim adds a touch of whimsy, while the blend of vanilla, almond, and cream brings serious flavor sophistication.

So whether you’re shaking one up for yourself or serving a batch to a crowd, you can’t go wrong with this sweet, sippable slice of Christmas joy. Add it to your holiday cocktail rotation—and prepare to be asked for the recipe again and again.

1. Can I make the Sugar Cookie Martini non-alcoholic?
Yes! Replace the vodka with vanilla syrup, the Irish cream with cream or flavored coffee creamer, and the amaretto with almond extract (just a few drops). Add milk and shake like usual.

2. How long does this cocktail last if made in advance?
It keeps well in the fridge for up to 3 days, but be sure to shake before serving as ingredients may separate.

3. Can I use dairy-free milk?
Absolutely. Oat milk and almond milk are great choices. Just avoid super watery options like rice milk for better texture.

4. What can I use instead of amaretto?
A few drops of almond extract can replace amaretto, or try hazelnut liqueur (like Frangelico) for a different nutty twist.

5. How do I store leftovers?
Pour leftovers into a sealed glass container and refrigerate. Shake before pouring again. Don’t store it rimmed—only garnish right before serving.

Sugar Cookie Martini

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star No reviews

Author: Lora

Print Recipe

Description

Ingredients

2 oz vanilla vodka
1 oz Irish cream
1 oz amaretto
1 oz milk (or milk alternative)
Frosting (for rimming the glass)
Holiday sprinkles (for garnish)

Ice

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Rim the Glass:
- Start by prepping your martini glass.
- Take a spoonful of vanilla or buttercream frosting and run it around the rim.
- Dip the frosted rim into a plate of colorful holiday sprinkles.
- Set the glass aside.

Mix the Drink:
- In a cocktail shaker filled with ice, pour in the vanilla vodka, Irish cream, amaretto, and milk.
- Shake vigorously for 15–20 seconds. You want everything super cold and well-blended.
Strain and Serve:
- Strain the mixture into your rimmed martini glass.
- Optional: Top with a small dollop of whipped cream or a mini sugar cookie for extra fun.

And voilà! You’ve got yourself a Sugar Cookie Martini that’s not only delicious but absolutely Instagram-worthy.

Hi, I’m Lora!

I'm so glad you've found your way here. My kitchen is my happy place, and if you're just starting your own cooking journey, I want you to know you're in the right place.

About Me